Your basket is ready and there's only one step left: choosing how to pay. Most of us click whatever is quickest. Yet the payment method decides whether you can get your money back if the store turns out to be fake or simply never ships your order.
We compare the most common ways to pay online: how they work, what protection they give you when an order doesn't arrive, and which scams to watch out for. At the end you'll find a ranking and a list of warning signs that mean you shouldn't pay at all. Rules differ between countries, so we use the UK and the US as examples where the law matters.
Check the store first, then choose how to pay
No payment method can turn a fake store into an honest one. The best protection is not paying a scammer in the first place. Before you choose how to pay, check the company details, independent reviews and the age of the domain. We explain how, step by step, in How to spot a fake online store.
The payment method is your second line of defence. It decides who can give you your money back, and on what basis, if something goes wrong.
How each payment method protects you
Credit and debit cards
How it works. On the payment page you enter your card number, expiry date and security code (CVV). Your bank will often ask you to confirm the payment in its app or with a one-time code. This is called 3-D Secure. Before you confirm, check the amount and the merchant's name. And remember: you never need your card PIN to shop online.
Protection. Cards give you the strongest tool: a chargeback. It's a claim your card issuer makes against the seller's bank under the card network's rules, for example when goods never arrive or the store doesn't refund you after a return.
A chargeback comes from card network rules, not from the law, and there is a time limit. UK guidance from MoneyHelper mentions 120 days from the purchase as a typical limit, but your bank's terms are what count. Some countries add legal protection on top for credit cards:
- UK: under section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act, your credit card provider is jointly liable with the seller for single items costing more than £100 and up to £30,000. It doesn't apply to debit cards.
- US: under the Fair Credit Billing Act, you can dispute a credit card charge for goods that weren't delivered as agreed. Send your dispute in writing within 60 days of the statement that first showed the charge.
Risks. On a fake website, scammers can steal your card details. You reduce the risk if your bank lets you set a limit for online payments or create a virtual card. Check your banking app.
Digital wallets: Apple Pay and Google Pay
How it works. You pay with a card stored in your phone's wallet and confirm with your fingerprint, face or passcode. Apple says Apple Pay doesn't share your actual card number with the merchant.
Protection. The money usually comes from the card behind the wallet, so ask your bank about a chargeback in the same way. Check the wallet's own terms to see what cover it offers.
Risks. Never add a card to a wallet, or approve a payment, because someone on the phone tells you to.
PayPal
How it works. You pay from a PayPal account linked to a card or bank account. The store doesn't see your card details.
Protection. PayPal offers buyer protection for purchases that never arrive or are significantly different from the description. You open a dispute in the Resolution Center within 180 days of the payment if the item never arrived. If it's significantly not as described, in the UK and US the limit is 30 days from delivery (and no more than 180 days from payment). If you can't agree with the seller, you can escalate the dispute to a claim, but you have to do it within 20 days or the dispute is closed. If PayPal rules in your favour, you get back the full price plus shipping. Protection doesn't cover, among other things, "Friends and Family" payments, vehicles or real estate, and PayPal decides whether a claim is eligible. Check the current terms for your country on paypal.com before you buy.
Risks. If a seller asks you to pay as "Friends and Family" because it's "cheaper", they're really asking you to give up your protection. Watch out for emails pretending to be from PayPal, too.
Bank transfer to an account number
How it works. The store gives you an account number and you send the money yourself from your bank.
Protection. Very little on the payment side. You authorised the transfer yourself, so the bank usually can't simply reverse it. If you suspect fraud, call your bank immediately: sometimes it can still act. Beyond that, you have a claim against the seller and can report the fraud to the police. In the UK, banks have had to reimburse most victims of authorised push payment scams sent by Faster Payments or CHAPS since 7 October 2024, up to £85,000 and subject to conditions, but it's far better not to need that.
Risks. A store where bank transfer is the only payment option is a classic warning sign. We describe it in Top 10 warning signs in an online store. If you still consider paying by transfer, check whether the account name matches the company on the store's website. In the UK, banks run a Confirmation of Payee check when you add a new payee: if the name doesn't match, don't pay. A "no match" result is a strong warning, while a match doesn't prove the store is honest.
Cash on delivery
How it works. You pay the courier or at a pick-up point once the parcel arrives.
Protection. You can't pay for something nobody sent. That's a real advantage with stores that take the money and disappear. But usually you pay before you open the parcel. If there's a counterfeit or something completely different inside, the money has already gone and you have to claim it back from the seller.
Risks. Don't accept a cash-on-delivery parcel you didn't order. Ask your household first whether anyone bought something.
Buy now, pay later
How it works. A buy now, pay later provider pays the store, and you pay the provider later, for example after 30 days or in instalments. It's a form of credit: miss a payment and you may face fees or interest, and missed payments can show up on your credit file.
Protection. If the store doesn't ship, you still owe the money, just to the provider rather than to the store. Some providers offer buyer protection, but the rules vary. Read the terms before you buy, and report a problem right away, before the payment is due. Don't just stop paying.
Ranking: how to pay at an unfamiliar store
The order reflects how much protection the payment method itself gives you if the store lets you down:
- A card confirmed in your banking app, ideally with a limit or as a virtual card. You can ask for a chargeback, and a credit card may give you extra legal protection.
- PayPal, as a payment for goods. You get buyer protection, and the store doesn't see your card details.
- A digital wallet linked to your card. The protection is mostly that of the card behind it.
- Cash on delivery. Protects you against a parcel that's never sent, but not against a counterfeit inside.
- Buy now, pay later. Protection depends on the provider's terms.
- Bank transfer to an account number. The least protection. Only with sellers you know well.
Red flags when paying
Stop the purchase if you notice any of these:
- The only option is a bank transfer to an account number.
- The store asks you to pay into a personal account, or an account whose name doesn't match the company.
- The seller wants payment in cryptocurrency, gift cards or by money transfer service. The US Federal Trade Commission warns that no legitimate business will insist you pay with a gift card.
- Someone asks for your card details by email, text, messaging app or for a photo of your card.
- The payment page is on an unfamiliar domain that belongs neither to a known payment provider nor to your bank, for example your bank's name with extra words added.
- Someone asks for a one-time code from your bank outside the store's checkout, for example on the phone or in a chat.
- The seller pushes you to use PayPal "Friends and Family".
- The store offers an extra discount for paying by bank transfer and rushes you with a countdown timer.
What Hubilado's verdict means when choosing a payment method
Hubilado doesn't see or handle your payments. It helps you decide whether and how to pay. When you ask, it reads the store's address and uses AI to analyse recent opinions and reviews, the seller's reputation and data-breach signals. It ignores subjective complaints, such as shipping delays.
- "safe": we found no evidence of scams. For a first purchase, still choose a method that lets you get your money back.
- "caution": think twice before you enter your card details or address. In practice, see whether you can buy the item elsewhere. If you do buy, don't pay by bank transfer and don't enter card details unnecessarily. PayPal or a virtual card with a limit is a better choice, and give only the details the order needs.
- "risk": stop. Don't pay by any method, because no payment method beats not buying at all.
You can check a store for free and without an account on the Hubilado homepage or with the Hubilado Chrome extension. Do it especially before big sales, when fake stores multiply. If you help your parents or grandparents with shopping, see also our guide on how to help older parents shop online safely.
What to do if you've already paid
Act straight away. Call your bank on the number from your card or app. If you paid by card, ask about a chargeback, and block the card if its details ended up on a suspicious website. If you paid with PayPal, open a dispute. We describe the whole process in Scammed by an online store: what to do, and you'll find where to report the store in How to report a fake online store.
Summary
- Check the store first, then choose how to pay.
- Cards and PayPal give you the most protection, but both have deadlines and exceptions.
- A bank transfer you authorised yourself is usually hard to reverse.
- "Bank transfer only", a personal account or a request for card details by email are all reasons to walk away.
- Cash on delivery protects you against a parcel that's never sent, not against a counterfeit.
