Article

Fake online store reviews: how to read Google and Trustpilot reviews before you buy

• Hubilado Team

How to tell genuine online store reviews from fake ones, what review labels really mean, and which negative reviews should stop you from buying.

Reviews from other customers are the first thing most of us check before buying from an unfamiliar store. That is exactly why scammers fake them. A 4.9-star rating means nothing if it was left by accounts created yesterday. On the other hand, a handful of angry comments doesn't automatically mean a store is dishonest.

This guide explains where to look for reviews, what the labels on review platforms actually mean, how to spot bought or fake reviews, and which complaints are a genuine red flag.

Reviews on the store's own website are not enough

The review widget on a store's website is controlled by the store owner. It can show nothing but praise, and on a fake store the whole section may simply be invented. That's why you should always look for reviews away from the store's website, on platforms the owner can't directly control. We cover this in Top 10 warning signs in an online store too.

Be wary of badges like "Trustpilot 4.9" or "Trusted store" pasted into the footer. A real badge usually links to the store's profile on that platform. If it's just an image with no link, type the store's address into the platform's own search and check the profile yourself.

What reviews mean on different platforms

Every platform collects reviews differently. Before you trust an average rating, find out who could have written it.

  • Trustpilot. Anyone can write a review, including people who never bought anything. Trustpilot labels a review "Verified" when it can confirm that a genuine interaction with the business took place, for example when the review came from an invitation the company sent after a purchase. A "Verified" label confirms the interaction, not that every claim in the review is true. If a company doesn't invite its customers to leave reviews, Trustpilot may show a note on the profile that the reviews may not be representative of all its customers.
  • Google (Maps and Business Profiles). Anyone with a Google account can leave a review. Google doesn't check whether the reviewer bought anything. A large number of reviews helps, but Google reviews on their own don't prove that a store is honest.
  • Marketplaces and price-comparison sites. Many large marketplaces and comparison sites show whether a review comes from a confirmed purchase. Check for that label, and compare the number of reviews with how long the store has been around.

Comparing several sources tells you the most. If a store has hundreds of glowing reviews in its own widget but none at all on independent platforms, or only complaints, treat that as a serious warning sign.

What the law says about fake reviews

Fake reviews are not just bad manners. In several major markets they are now explicitly illegal:

  • United States. The Federal Trade Commission's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials took effect on 21 October 2024. It bans businesses from writing, buying or selling fake reviews, from suppressing negative reviews, and from passing off a company-controlled review site as independent. Courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations.
  • United Kingdom. Since 6 April 2025, under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act, submitting or commissioning fake reviews, or hiding the fact that a review was incentivised, is a banned practice. Websites that publish reviews must take reasonable steps to prevent and remove fake ones. The Competition and Markets Authority can fine businesses up to 10% of their global turnover.
  • European Union. Stores that display reviews must say whether and how they check that reviews come from people who actually bought or used the product. Fake reviews and misleading presentation of reviews are banned.

In practice this means an honest store has no reason to hide how its reviews are collected. If you can't find that information on a store that sells into the EU, it doesn't prove fraud, but it's a reason to be more careful.

How to spot fake reviews: 8 signs

  1. Lots of reviews in a short time. Dozens of reviews within a few days, especially right after a store launches, rarely happen naturally.
  2. Reviews older than the store. If the reviews date back years but the store's domain is brand new, something doesn't add up. You can check when a domain was registered with ICANN's free lookup tool at lookup.icann.org. For some country-code domains, use the national registry's own lookup instead.
  3. Vague praise with no details. Lines like "Great store, highly recommend, all good" say nothing about the product, delivery or service. Real customers usually mention specifics, such as sizing, delivery time or how the store handled a question.
  4. The same style and repeated phrases. Identical wording, reviews of the same length and odd, machine-translated language suggest one person or one program wrote them.
  5. Accounts with a single review. Click on the reviewer's profile. An account with no history, or one that rated dozens of unrelated businesses on the same day, is a classic sign of bought reviews.
  6. Nothing but five stars. Honest stores have unhappy customers too. A profile with no critical reviews at all is less believable than one with a few specific complaints and replies from the store.
  7. Reviews of a different product. Reviews describing items the store doesn't even sell have often been copied from another website.
  8. Suspicious replies from the store. Copy-and-paste replies to every complaint, blaming the customer, or asking reviewers to get in touch somewhere else, for example on a messaging app, should catch your attention.

One of these signs on its own isn't proof. Several at once should send you looking for another seller.

Which negative reviews really matter

Not every complaint means a scam. Some reviews describe ordinary hassles that happen at reliable stores too:

  • the courier was a day or two late,
  • customer service took a few days to reply,
  • the parcel was badly packed,
  • the product didn't meet someone's expectations, even though it matched the description.

These are subjective reviews. They're worth reading, but on their own they don't show that a store is dishonest.

Treat complaints very differently when they repeat and describe lost money:

  • I paid and the goods never arrived,
  • the store didn't refund me after I cancelled the order,
  • I received a counterfeit or a completely different product,
  • the store stopped replying once the payment went through,
  • the returns address turned out to be in another country, even though the store presented itself as local.

If several independent people describe situations like these, especially in recent weeks, don't buy from that store. If it has already happened to you, read what to do if you've been scammed by an online store and how to report a fake online store.

How Hubilado reads reviews for you

Checking several review platforms by hand takes time, and not everyone knows what to look for. Hubilado does it automatically: it analyses recent opinions and reviews of the store and looks for evidence of scams and undelivered orders.

Hubilado ignores subjective complaints, such as shipping delays or slow replies from customer service. That way one grumpy review won't sink a reliable store, while a run of reports about parcels that never arrived won't go unnoticed. After the label "Recommendation:" you get one of three verdicts:

  • "safe", a green light: we found no evidence of scams or undelivered orders,
  • "caution", when something raises doubts. Think twice before you enter your card details or address,
  • "risk", when the store has a proven bad reputation. Stop any activity on the site.

You don't need an account. Enter the store's address on the Hubilado homepage or use the Chrome extension.

Summary: checklist before you buy

  • I've checked reviews on at least two independent platforms, not just on the store's website.
  • I know whether the reviews are linked to real purchases (for example, the "Verified" label on Trustpilot).
  • The review dates match the store's age, and the reviews didn't all appear at once.
  • The reviews are specific, and the reviewers have a history on the platform.
  • The latest reviews don't contain repeated complaints about missing goods or missing refunds.

For more ways to check a store, such as verifying company details and payment methods, see How to spot a fake online store in 5 steps.